COVERGIRL Reviews

COVERGIRL has an overall rating of 4.3 based on 23 reviews. Customer feedback on COVERGIRL is mixed: COVERGIRL reviewers highlight positive aspects like affordable prices, wide product range, good quality, easy online shopping, which strongly appeal to budget-conscious beauty enthusiasts. However, COVERGIRL is often criticized for its limited shade options, occasional shipping delays, customer service issues, website navigation challenges.

4.3/5.0

23 reviews

5 Stars

12

4 Stars

5

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All COVERGIRL Reviews (23)
sue.Holloway
May 25, 2026
"I got my COVERGIRL order today and, i..."
I got my COVERGIRL order today and, i was a little confused at first because I expected something to be off for some reason. But everything was exactly right, the shades and items all matched what I picked. No mix-ups at all, so I’m happy with it.
sherry-Costello
May 19, 2026
"Feels nice, not too much"
I like this stuff so far. It feels soft when I put it on, and it doesn’t have that sticky feeling some of them have. Just nice and light.
hello_marie648
May 17, 2026
"I ordered a few Covergirl items and..."
I ordered a few Covergirl items and braced myself for the classic waiting game, but then—plot twist, my package showed up in about 3 days. I was genuinely surprised because I had fully prepared to be checking the mailbox like a dramatic character in a movie.

The only reason I’m sticking with 4 stars is because the tracking didn’t update right away, so for a minute I was wondering if my order had vanished into the shipping void. Thankfully, everything arrived just fine and way faster than I expected
Amber_davis72
May 01, 2026
"Some products are hit or miss"
I’ve tried a few covergirl products, it’s been kind of a mixed bag for me. The mascara was actually good, but the foundation looked patchy on my skin and didn’t wear the way I hoped. When I mentioned it, I kind of felt dismissed, like it was just my skin and not the product. It’s not terrible overall, but the quality doesn’t feel super consistent for me.
Trent_henderson82
April 29, 2026
"Super easy to find what I needed"
I had a really smooth experience using the site and found what I was looking for quickly. It was simple, straightforward, and kind of refreshing!
thomas1986
April 28, 2026
"I ordered a few things from covergirl.com, and..."
I ordered a few things from covergirl.com, and for me, the whole delivery experience felt easy and stress-free.
I got the tracking info soon after ordering, and the package actually showed up when it was supposed to. I’m always a little nervous with makeup being shipped because something can spill, crack, or go missing, but everything was packed fine and arrived in good shape.
It wasn’t some over-the-top experience, but that’s kind of what I appreciate. The order came on time, nothing was damaged, and I’d be comfortable ordering from them again when I need to restock
Clyde-hajdas
April 24, 2026
"I grabbed a few makeup items..."
I grabbed a few makeup items while they had a discount going, and I feel like it was actually a really good deal. The prices were better than what I usually see at my local store, which is always nice, right? The promo code went through without any issues, and checkout was easy too. Overall, I’m happy with it and would probably order again.
Joseph_wright84
April 17, 2026
"I swear covergirl.com has saved me from..."
I swear covergirl.com has saved me from a full-on makeup crisis more than once. Whenever my foundation or mascara is sold out everywhere else, I check here and somehow they actually have my shades in stock. It feels like a tiny miracle every time because I get way too dramatic when I can’t find my usual products. Checkout was easy too, no drama there. Definitely 5 stars from me.
JohnKirchausen
April 15, 2026
"Finally found my shade"
I finally found my shade and honestly... it was easy. There were a lot of options, so I could actually find a match that worked for me, which was nice...
kathynorris5226
April 12, 2026
"Packaging was Really Nice"
My order got here in Good shape and nothing was leaking or cracked, which i was happy about. The makeup was packed neatly and the box wasn’t all smashed up or anything. overall, happy with how it showed up.
james1977
March 30, 2026
"Good first impression with an easy checkout"
My first impression of COVERGIRL was positive because the shopping process felt simple right away. I found what I was looking for, added it to my cart, and the checkout moved along without dragging. My info saved correctly too, and the payment went through with no issues.

The only part that threw me off a bit was the promo code box, which wasn’t super clear at first. One page also loaded kind of slowly, but it only happened once and wasn’t a huge deal. Overall, it was a smooth experience and I’d shop there again.
TheresaGalindo_57
March 18, 2026
"Check the ingredients before buying"
Some of the products seem fine, but I noticed a few ingredients in there that I personally try to stay away from. It’s not the worst, and I wouldn’t say it’s a total dealbreaker, but I also don’t fully trust it. Just a heads up to anyone buying—definitely read the label first.
RitaNewman
March 16, 2026
"The color looked a little different in..."
The color looked a little different in person than it did online, so that was slightly disappointing. To be fair, screens can make shades look different, and it’s still perfectly usable. Just not exactly the color I thought I was getting
josephinecherry3601
March 06, 2026
"Looks good at first, but fades too fast"
It looks really nice when I first put it on, but after a few hours it starts fading on me. It’s not awful or anything, I’m just kind of tired of products promising all-day wear and then not really delivering. I don’t want to have to keep touching it up or deal with another return/customer service thing, so I’ll probably just use it when I only need it for a short time...
june_Sepulveda87
January 22, 2026
"Fair prices, decent everyday basics"
I’ve ordered from covergirl.com a couple times, and the prices are good for everyday makeup. I don’t have the patience to fuss around with products that take forever to make work, so I like that most of what I’ve tried is easy enough and does the job. Not every item is amazing, but for daily use, a lot of it is perfectly fine. Shipping was okay too. I’d give it 4 stars.
joan_Standish02
January 19, 2026
"Honestly, the applicator is good"
I wasn’t expecting much, but the applicator actually works really well. It goes on easily and I didn’t have any issues with clumps
Kelly-amaker
January 16, 2026
"I have sensitive skin, and a lot..."
I have sensitive skin, and a lot of makeup makes me itchy or causes breakouts. But this Covergirl foundation I ordered from covergirl.com has been good so far, like actually good. No redness, no heavy feeling, and my skin hasn’t freaked out. The shade match was close too. Shipping was normal, nothing weird or anything. I’m happy with it and I’d definitely buy it again
johnodebralski4095
January 10, 2026
"Return was easy, refund took a bit"
The return process itself was straightforward, which I appreciated. The refund did take longer than I expected, though I don’t really have the full picture on why it was delayed, so maybe it was just a one-off. Overall, not a terrible experience, just a little slower than I hoped.
SHEHAN
December 23, 2025
"Pretty good, but not magic"
It does a solid job covering redness, which is what most of these products are supposed to do anyway. It looks good at first, but like basically every makeup product ever, I had to touch it up later in the day
Jacqueline_schuster02
December 20, 2025
"Nice everyday scent"
I really like this one. The scent is soft and not overpowering at all, which makes it easy to wear every day. Compared to a lot of other perfumes people around me wear, this feels more subtle and clean, but still noticeable in a nice way.

View More Reviews

Have a question about COVERGIRL?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.